Journal · Recovery

Breathing rate is the vital sign nobody watches

Heart rate gets the charts and HRV gets the headlines. Your resting breathing rate barely moves from night to night, which is why a change in it is worth a look.

· 5 min read · by Wave Wellness

There are four classic vital signs: temperature, pulse, blood pressure and breathing rate. Three of them come with a device. The fourth comes with a nurse glancing at a patient’s chest for a few seconds, if anyone checks it at all.

In 2008 a group of Australian clinicians reviewed how hospitals handled it and gave their paper a blunt title: “Respiratory rate: the neglected vital sign” (Cretikos, 2008). They found it was often not recorded, and often estimated rather than counted, even though a rising rate was one of the more reliable early signs that a patient was getting worse. Hospital early warning scores now give it real weight for that reason.

Most people who track their health share the blind spot. Heart rate gets a chart. HRV gets the articles. Breathing rate sits quietly at the bottom of the screen.

A number that barely moves

The usual range for a resting adult is about 12 to 20 breaths a minute. That range is wide, but your own number is not. Asleep, with nothing asking anything of you, your breathing settles into a rate that tends to sit within a narrow band of its usual level from one night to the next.

That steadiness is what makes it useful. HRV swings with a drink, a hard session, a bad night or a stressful day, so a single low reading is usually noise. Resting heart rate is steadier, and a few beats either way is ordinary. Overnight breathing rate is steadier still. Because it changes so little on an ordinary night, a change that holds for more than a night is harder to dismiss.

What tends to move it

Breathing rises when the body needs more from it. A fever does it. So does a body fighting something off, and so does a climb to altitude, where each breath carries less oxygen. The rate also rises with exertion, of course, which is why only a resting reading is worth comparing.

Wearable data has started to show this at scale. In 2020, researchers working with WHOOP data looked at nighttime breathing rate in people who later tested positive for COVID-19 and found that it rose in many of them around the time they fell ill, in some before they noticed symptoms (Miller, 2020). It was an early, observational study of one illness, and a rising number is not a diagnosis of anything. But it shows the kind of signal this is: quiet for weeks, then a step up that means the body is busy with something.

The useful reading is your own. “Higher than my usual for three nights running” is a far better question than “is 17 normal?”

Breathing on purpose is a different measurement

There is a catch, and it explains a decision in the app. You can change your breathing rate at will in a way you cannot change your heart rate. The moment you notice your breathing, it changes. That is the whole basis of slow, paced breathing, and it is also why a breathing rate measured while you are paying attention is not a resting rate.

So the best resting reading is one you are not awake for. Overnight, a wearable can count breaths without you knowing it is counting.

How Wave reads it

Wave Wellness collects breathing rate from two places and treats them differently, on purpose.

Overnight, from a wearable. WHOOP reports a respiratory rate each night, and Wave brings it in with your sleep, recovery and HRV. When it is there, the Sleep side of the app shows it plainly: breaths a minute asleep. This is the reading worth watching for a change from your own usual.

From the camera, with a caveat. The WellnessScan reads breathing rate off the same pulse trace it uses for heart rate: slow breathing sways the whole signal, and the sway is measured. But the scan also runs a breathing coach at six breaths a minute, because pacing is what makes its breath response readable. If you follow the coach, the scan reads about six, and it says what that means: you followed the pacer. It measured the coach, not you.

That is why Wave Age, the long view, uses breathing rate carefully. It reads only scans where you did not follow the pacer, averages up to the last three, and throws out anything outside 8 to 30 as noise. It is also given very little weight: a resting rate over 20 adds half a year, and a rate at or under 20 adds nothing. Resting heart rate, fitness, sleep and the rest carry far more, each with its study named in “What moves it”.

Today’s Wave, the daily score, does not use breathing rate. It reads HRV, resting heart rate, sleep, yesterday’s strain and your check-in, so a breathing number never quietly moves your morning.

What it cannot tell you

A breathing rate is a count, not a lung test. Nothing here measures how much air moves, how well oxygen gets in, or anything about asthma or sleep apnea. A camera reading at a desk is an estimate, and a wearable’s overnight figure is a good estimate, not a clinical measurement.

It also cannot say why. A higher rate for a few nights might be a cold coming on, a late heavy meal, a warm room, a hard week of training or nothing at all. The value of a quiet number is that it tells you when to pay attention. What you do next is a judgment, and if a change comes with feeling unwell, it is a judgment for a doctor.

The idea works without any app. On an ordinary, rested morning, lie still before you get up and count your breaths for a full minute without trying to change them. Watching will slow it a little, so do it a few mornings and keep the usual. Know it the way you know your usual weight. A number you know is one you will notice when it moves.

Wave Wellness is free on the App Store and Google Play. Download it and see your own nights, breathing included today.

Wave is for general wellness and is not a medical device. It does not diagnose or treat anything; talk to a doctor about breathing that is faster than usual, or any shortness of breath.

See this number in your own record.

Wave reads it every morning and tells you, in plain English, what changed.